Social, Ethical & Labor Compliance Audit
Audits wages, working hours, structural and fire safety, and forced or child-labour risks against global standards — SMETA, BSCI and SA8000 — to protect buyer reputation.
SMETA, BSCI And SA8000 Side By Side
The three differ less in what they examine than in who owns the scheme, who accepts the result, what the output is, and how much rigour it carries. Pick by what your buyer will accept, not by the length of the checklist.
SMETA
amfori BSCI
SA8000
What A Social Audit Actually Examines
SA8000:2014 sets out nine requirement areas. Whichever scheme your buyer names, these are the questions an auditor is working through on the floor.
| # | Element | What The Auditor Is Establishing |
|---|---|---|
| 01 | Child labour | Age at hiring verified against original documents, not copies; no worker below the legal minimum; remediation where a young worker is found rather than dismissal. |
| 02 | Forced or compulsory labour | No deposits, no retained identity documents, no wage withholding, no debt bondage through recruitment fees, and freedom to leave at the end of a shift. |
| 03 | Health and safety | Building, fire and electrical condition, exit adequacy, machine guarding, chemical handling, and whether safety certificates come from recognised bodies. |
| 04 | Freedom of association | The right to organise and bargain collectively in practice, not only on paper, and whether worker representatives are genuinely elected. |
| 05 | Discrimination | Hiring, pay, promotion and dismissal tested for differences by gender, pregnancy, religion, origin or union membership. |
| 06 | Disciplinary practices | No corporal punishment, no verbal abuse, no coercion, and a grievance route workers can actually use without reprisal. |
| 07 | Working hours | Hours actually worked against hours recorded, weekly rest, overtime consent, and whether a second set of records exists. |
| 08 | Remuneration | Pay against the legal minimum, overtime premium, lawful deductions, payment route and whether payroll reconciles to attendance. |
| 09 | Management system | Whether the other eight are managed deliberately — policy, responsibility, risk assessment, worker involvement, corrective action and review. |
How Non-Conformities Are Graded
Schemes use their own wording, but the shape is the same everywhere: a few findings stop the order, most need a dated fix, and the rest are worth doing before they grow.
The Audit Pack
Social And Labour Audit FAQs
What is a social, ethical and labour compliance audit?
It is an on-site examination of wages, working hours, structural and fire safety, and forced or child-labour risk, measured against a named global standard such as SMETA, amfori BSCI or SA8000. It combines document review, records reconciliation, physical inspection and private worker interviews, and produces a graded list of findings with a dated plan to close them.
Which of the three is a certification?
Only SA8000. SMETA is an audit methodology owned by Sedex — it produces a report uploaded to the Sedex platform, with no pass mark and no certificate. amfori BSCI is a due-diligence audit and monitoring system, also not a certification. SA8000 is a certifiable management system standard: an accredited body decides to certify and issues a time-bound certificate, which means the credential belongs to the site rather than to the buyer who commissioned an audit.
How long is an SA8000 certificate valid?
Three years, issued by a body accredited for the scheme, with surveillance audits during the cycle rather than a single visit at the start. That structure is the practical difference from a commissioned audit: the certificate stays live only if the site keeps meeting the standard between visits, so it cannot be earned by preparing for one day.
What is the difference between a 2-pillar and 4-pillar SMETA?
A 2-pillar SMETA covers labour standards and health and safety. A 4-pillar adds environment and business ethics. Confirm which one your buyer wants before booking, because the scope, duration and cost differ and a 2-pillar report will not satisfy a buyer expecting four. If a buyer says only “upload to Sedex”, ask them to specify the pillar count in writing.
If we hold SA8000, do we still need BSCI?
Generally not while the certificate is valid. The amfori BSCI Code of Conduct was developed in partnership with Social Accountability International as a stepping stone towards SA8000, and a site holding a valid SA8000 certificate is usually not asked to implement the BSCI code separately. Confirm it with the specific buyer, since acceptance is their decision rather than a rule of either scheme.
What are the nine SA8000 elements?
Child labour; forced or compulsory labour; health and safety; freedom of association and the right to collective bargaining; discrimination; disciplinary practices; working hours; remuneration; and the management system for continuous improvement. The first eight describe conditions. The ninth asks whether those conditions are managed deliberately, which is what determines whether they hold after the auditor leaves.
Can you issue an SA8000 certificate?
No, and neither can any audit firm that is not an accredited certification body for the scheme. Certification is a separate, accredited function and we do not perform it. What we do is audit against the standard your buyer names, prepare a site for a certification audit by identifying what would fail it, and verify afterwards that findings were genuinely closed. Anyone offering to sell you a certificate directly is worth declining.
How are worker interviews kept safe?
Privately, away from the production floor and out of earshot of supervisors, with workers selected by the auditor rather than presented by management, and with the sample spread across shifts, lines and roles. Findings are reported only in aggregate: no comment is attributed to a named individual, and no interview content goes back to factory management in a form that could identify who said it. An audit that exposes a worker to retaliation has done more harm than running no audit at all.
